Home buyer’s remorse: red flags you shouldn’t ignore

Buying a home is a significant investment that requires careful consideration. This article presents crucial red flags that potential homebuyers should not overlook, backed by insights from industry experts. By understanding these warning signs, readers can make informed decisions and avoid costly mistakes in their home-buying journey.

LOCAL NEWS: 100 best places to work and live in Arizona for 2025

INDUSTRY INSIGHTS: Want more news like this? Get our free newsletter here

  • Hydrostatic Tests Prevent Costly Plumbing Surprises
  • Scrutinize Property Grading to Avoid Water Issues
  • Push for Full Disclosure to Prevent Hidden Problems
  • Consider Daily Functionality When Evaluating Home Layout
  • Address Minor Plumbing Issues Before Purchasing
  • Inspect Roof Age to Avoid Unexpected Replacements
  • Thorough Inspections Prevent Expensive Foundation Repairs
  • Outdated Electrical Systems Can Spark Major Expenses
  • Evaluate Property Grading to Prevent Drainage Problems
  • Clarify Fence Ownership Before Finalizing Home Purchase
  • Trust Your Nose During Home Inspections
  • Neighborhood Amenities Impact Long-Term Property Value
  • Take Water Damage Hints Seriously During Inspection
  • Test Mobile Signal Strength Throughout Potential Home
  • Assess Solar Orientation for Energy Efficiency

Hydrostatic Tests Prevent Costly Plumbing Surprises

As both a Realtor and property flipper, one red flag I regret ignoring was skipping a hydrostatic plumbing test on a house we bought in the early days of our home buyer business.

The property had old cast iron pipes leaking underground (roots from a big tree nearby). Replacing them with PVC cost us about $15,000, which completely blew the renovation budget. What should have been a profitable project ended up breaking even all because we didn’t spend $350 upfront on a plumbing test.

Now I strongly recommend hydrostatic tests for every client buying an older home in Texas. Especially with houses built before the 1980s, it’s a small investment that can prevent a massive financial setback.

Get the plumbing test. It’s one of the best $350 decisions you’ll ever make.

Hilary Schultz, Co-Founder, Uncle Tex Buys Houses

Scrutinize Property Grading to Avoid Water Issues

For me, one red flag I ignored when buying my home was the inconsistent grading and drainage around the property. At the time, I was so focused on the home’s layout and location that I brushed it off as a small landscaping fix. In reality, that oversight ended up causing some water pooling issues during the rainy season, something that could have been avoided with a bit more scrutiny during the inspection process.

It’s easy to get emotionally attached when you find a home that “feels right,” but that’s exactly when you need to slow down and look at the less glamorous details. My advice to buyers is to pay close attention to the structural and environmental factors, things like drainage, roof condition, foundation cracks, or even signs of previous water damage. These aren’t exciting, but they can be very expensive if ignored.

I always tell clients: don’t get swept up by staging or paint colors. Bring a contractor to your second showing if you’re unsure, and never hesitate to ask the tough questions. A beautiful kitchen won’t mean much if you’re dealing with water in your basement a few months later.

Adam Chahl, Owner / Realtor, Vancouver Home Search

Push for Full Disclosure to Prevent Hidden Problems

The home-buying process can be tiring and even frustratingly long and tedious. This makes it easier to overlook certain things that might feel wrong or look suspicious in a desperate attempt to just get things over with.

When buying my home, one red flag I ignored and soon came to regret overlooking was the seller’s reluctance to provide full disclosure about the property’s history. After the transaction was completed and I moved in, I discovered some water damage and mold issues. Had I pushed the issue hard enough, chances are that I would have been able to negotiate the problems into the sale, or better still, have gotten the seller to cover the costs of the repairs. The truth is, the major reason I ignored these red flags was due to my eagerness to finalize the purchase. Plus, I had already lost two properties to other buyers, and I was worried that if I didn’t act fast and show enough commitment to the purchase, the seller would accept another offer.

My mistake, however, was in failing to balance this fear with a thorough evaluation of the property’s condition, potential risks, and the costs that they would be accompanied by. This is why I would advise others in similar situations to instead take their time to prioritize thorough research and evaluation. The truth is that fear of losing the home could easily cloud your judgment and result in costly mistakes and regrets down the line.

Nathan Richardson, Founder, Business owner and leader, CashForHome

Consider Daily Functionality When Evaluating Home Layout

One red flag I completely ignored when buying my home—and deeply regret—was underestimating how disruptive a poorly designed layout can be. The square footage seemed perfect, the location was ideal, and everything checked out on paper. But what I failed to consider was how the space actually functioned in day-to-day life. Over time, I realized small inefficiencies were making a huge impact: the kitchen felt disconnected from the social areas, the bedroom placement amplified noise, and the entryway was awkward, creating congestion. These weren’t obvious issues during the initial walk-through, but living in the home turned them into daily frustrations.

Now, my advice to others is never to judge a home purely by its features—walk through it as if you already live there. Picture your routines, storage needs, and movement flow. If something feels even slightly unnatural, it will only become more frustrating over time. A home should support your life effortlessly, not create invisible stress. The true measure of livability isn’t just in aesthetics—it’s in how seamlessly the space supports your rhythm.

Seymen Usta, Interior Designer, Modern Chandelier

Address Minor Plumbing Issues Before Purchasing

When I bought my home, I ignored what seemed like a minor issue at the time: inconsistent water pressure. It didn’t seem like a big deal during the walkthrough, and the agent brushed it off as “probably just a temporary thing.” I was focused on the layout, the neighborhood, and how quickly the market was moving. But once I moved in, that small red flag turned into a major plumbing headache. We had to replace old pipes that were clogging up and restricting flow throughout the house. It was costly, messy, frustrating, and avoidable.

Looking back, I’d tell anyone buying a home to slow down and dig deeper when something feels off, even if it seems small. Don’t get so caught up in the excitement that you overlook the basics. If a faucet trickles or a toilet doesn’t flush right, press for answers. Bring in a professional if needed. A home inspection is excellent, but it’s not foolproof. Sometimes, it’s those little quirks that reveal bigger issues. I learned the hard way that “probably nothing” can turn into “definitely something” once the papers are signed and the moving truck’s gone. Trust your gut and don’t rush.

Patrick Dinehart, CMO, ReallyCheapFloors.com

Inspect Roof Age to Avoid Unexpected Replacements

One of the most significant mistakes I made when purchasing my home was overlooking the roof’s age—a red flag I should never have ignored. At the time, it seemed to be in good condition and didn’t show any obvious signs of damage or wear. However, as time went on, I started to notice small leaks and eventually had to replace the entire roof. In hindsight, I regret not having a professional inspection done specifically on the roof before purchasing my home. It would have saved me a lot of money and stress in the long run.

My advice to others who are in a similar situation is to always get a thorough inspection done by a reputable professional before finalizing your purchase. Don’t just rely on your own observations or trust the word of the seller. Additionally, always make sure to carefully read and understand any disclosures provided by the seller. These may highlight potential issues or repairs that need to be made.

Patrick McDermott, Executive Vice President, Max Cash

Thorough Inspections Prevent Expensive Foundation Repairs

When I bought my first home, I overlooked the importance of a thorough inspection—even after noticing minor water spots in the basement—thinking I could fix it later. That mistake ended up costing me far more in foundation repairs than I anticipated. My advice: never ignore even small issues, especially with basements or roofs. Bringing in a trusted inspector up front can save you thousands and prevent a lot of headaches down the road.

Parker McInnis, Owner, Speedy Sale Home Buyers

Outdated Electrical Systems Can Spark Major Expenses

When I bought my first home, I ignored the outdated electrical system. The inspector mentioned it casually, and I was so focused on the layout and natural light that I brushed it off. Fast forward a few months, and I had to rewire half the house because the circuits couldn’t handle basic appliances without tripping. It wasn’t just expensive; it was also a major inconvenience right after moving in.

If you’re buying a home, my advice is simple: don’t let charm distract you from function. When an inspector flags something, even in passing, press for details. Ask what it would cost to fix today, not someday. And get quotes from professionals before you close. It’s far easier to negotiate repairs or pricing than to discover you’re living in a fire hazard with great windows.

Georgi Petrov, CMO, Entrepreneur, and Content Creator, AIG MARKETER

Evaluate Property Grading to Prevent Drainage Problems

I ignored a subtle but critical red flag: the grading around the home sloped slightly toward the foundation. It seemed cosmetic at the time. Months later, it translated into drainage issues, pooling water, and a costly retrofit to regrade and install a French drain system. My advice? Bring a contractor, not just an inspector, and walk the perimeter of the property after a good rain. Cosmetics are easy to change; water problems are not. That oversight taught me more about value than any spreadsheet ever could.

Erwin Gutenkunst, President and Owner, Neolithic Materials

Clarify Fence Ownership Before Finalizing Home Purchase

What I regret was brushing off the condition of the shared fence during the walkthrough. It looked weathered but still upright, and at the time, I figured it would be a small fix if it ever came up. What I did not think about was ownership. Once I moved in and wanted to repair it, I hit a wall, both literally and legally. My neighbor claimed the entire fence was theirs, even the side facing my property. I couldn’t touch it, couldn’t repair it, couldn’t replace it, and they weren’t interested in maintaining it either. It leans, it’s rotting at the base, and it honestly looks like it’s been through a wind tunnel.

If I could do it over, I would’ve asked one question before signing anything: who actually owns that fence? Not just a guess, not just what the listing agent assumes. I would’ve asked to see it in writing. If it was shared, I would’ve wanted an agreement in place or at least a conversation with the neighbor ahead of time. It’s not about the money. The problem wasn’t the cost. It was dealing with something on my property that I couldn’t even fix because someone else had full control over it. That’s the part I regret most. It’s a small thing that becomes a long-term nuisance. And once you’re in, it’s yours to deal with, no matter how simple it looked from the outside.

James Myers, Sales Director and Office Manager, VINEVIDA

Trust Your Nose During Home Inspections

One red flag I ignored was a musty smell in the basement. I thought it was nothing and assumed it was just because the house had been closed up. However, after I moved in, I discovered there was moisture and even some mold. It cost me time and money to fix. My advice: don’t ignore smells or anything that feels off. Always get a thorough home inspection and ask questions. It’s better to be safe than sorry.

Joseph Commisso, Owner, WeBuyHousesQuick.ca

Neighborhood Amenities Impact Long-Term Property Value

When I bought my house, I thought it was acceptable that the area lacked amenities. There were no good schools, few parks, and the nearest grocery store or café was a drive away. At the time, I focused more on the structure and price. I believed I was buying for the house, not the neighborhood.

However, that turned out to be a significant mistake. I didn’t consider how much the lack of nearby amenities would impact the long-term value of the house. So when it was time to sell, the absence of parks, schools, and local shops made the property much less attractive to potential buyers. Families weren’t interested, and neither were young professionals. The neighborhood’s isolation was a considerable barrier, and those missing amenities ultimately made the property much harder to sell.

This is why I advise anyone considering buying a home to pay close attention to the surrounding area, not just the house itself. The neighborhood affects the property’s future value and livability. Missing amenities like parks, schools, or nearby shops might not seem like a big deal at first, but they play a significant role in how others view the property. What works for you now may not appeal to future buyers, so always consider how the area will impact your investment in the long run.

Dorian Menard, SEO Strategy Director and Founder, Search Scope

Take Water Damage Hints Seriously During Inspection

I once ignored a tiny crack in a basement wall because it seemed minor. I regretted it later when rainwater started coming in. As home inspectors often say, “If it has had water problems in the past, it will have water problems again.” My advice is, don’t brush off any hint of water or foundation trouble. Get a professional inspection that checks for leaks and grading around the house. If the buyer or seller mentions any water damage history, dig deeper. It is better to pay for preventive fixes up front than to fix a flooded basement down the line.

David Grossman, Founder & Chief Growth Officer, Lessn

Test Mobile Signal Strength Throughout Potential Home

I ignored poor mobile signal during inspections. I thought it was minor—it turned out it blocked client calls, delayed work communications, and hindered my ability to manage team operations on the fly.

If you run a business or work remotely, this issue matters. Test coverage in multiple locations, at different times of day. Don’t just trust the provider maps; they’re often inaccurate.

The same principle applies in marketing: small issues left unchecked often create bigger problems. Always validate your assumptions before committing. One missed signal can cost more than you anticipate.

Callum Gracie, Founder, Otto Media

Assess Solar Orientation for Energy Efficiency

I neglected to address poor solar orientation, a critical mistake. The house functioned wonderfully on paper, but in key living areas, it’s dark and cold, which has a significant impact on comfort and energy usage year-round.

Had I focused on passive design from the beginning, I could have saved thousands in heating and cooling bills. My advice? Don’t get distracted by decorative finishes; focus on how the house truly functions across seasons. Ask for solar reports and combine those with AI-based simulations.

Sean Willams, Founder, Brick Brick

Related Articles