Overwhelmed parents: how to find the right balance between structured and unstructured play
Parenting in today’s world can be overwhelming, especially when it comes to balancing structured and unstructured play for children. This article presents valuable insights from experts in child development and parenting. Discover practical strategies to foster creativity, independence, and essential skills in your children while finding the right balance in their playtime.
DEEPER DIVE: 20 emerging business categories gaining traction in Arizona
INDUSTRY INSIGHTS: Want more news like this? Get our free newsletter here
- Embrace Boredom as a Creative Opportunity
- Balance Structure with Unstructured Play
- Model Self-Regulation for Your Children
- Foster Independent Play Skills
- Allow Boredom to Spark Creativity
- Recognize Your Parenting Efforts
- Provide Space for Growth and Imagination
- Combine Free Play with Guided Activities
- Tolerate Boredom to Develop Essential Skills
- Let Go of Guilt and Embrace Chaos
Embrace Boredom as a Creative Opportunity
Boredom isn’t a problem; it’s a starting point. You don’t need to fill your child’s day with Instagram-worthy outings or Pinterest-level activities. Children also need unstructured playtime because this is where creativity, resilience, confidence, and self-direction come from.
So, instead of aiming to entertain them constantly, think about creating a safe space where your little ones can explore, tinker, and experiment with different things. The balance between structure and freedom doesn’t have to be perfect.
For example, you can set aside morning hours for planned activities and afternoons for unstructured play or “figure it out” time. When it is time for unstructured play, only provide them with materials, not instructions.
Rotate toys, offer open-ended prompts, and let them be creative. You are not slacking—instead, you are giving them the ability to make their own fun and enjoy the moment.
Paul Zalewski, Co-Founder, Fathercraft
Balance Structure with Unstructured Play
Many parents today feel pressured to constantly entertain their children, but what they often overlook is that boredom isn’t a problem; it’s an opportunity. Unstructured play is not only natural but essential for a child’s healthy development. In fact, research published in the journal Pediatrics emphasizes that unstructured play enhances creativity, self-regulation, and emotional resilience.
Striking the Right Balance
- Let go of the guilt: Children don’t need non-stop stimulation. They thrive in environments where imagination leads.
- Designate quiet play zones: Safe, screen-free spaces with open-ended toys—like blocks, crayons, or pretend-play props—encourage independent thinking.
- Limit overscheduling: While structured activities like sports or music are valuable, packing every hour can lead to stress—for both parents and children.
- Embrace “bored” moments: These are often when kids come up with the most creative ideas.
- Model calmness: Children mirror adult behavior. When you’re relaxed about downtime, they learn to value it too.
Remember, childhood doesn’t need to be curated minute by minute. A healthy mix of structure and freedom allows children to grow into curious, capable, and emotionally intelligent individuals. Parents, give yourselves permission to just be—you’re doing more than enough.
Dr Sankeerth Yellinedi, Neonatologist and Paediatrician, Marwellus Clinic & Diagnostics
Model Self-Regulation for Your Children
Feel the pressure, but don’t let it drive your decisions.
It’s completely normal to feel overwhelmed, especially with the idea that you need to constantly entertain your child. However, remember that children learn more from what we model than what we say. Take a moment to notice the pressure, acknowledge the overwhelm, and allow those emotions to move through you instead of reacting to them.
Self-regulation is an important skill, and it often starts with co-regulation, which begins with you. When you pause, take a breath, and do something nurturing to ground yourself, you’re showing your child how to handle stress and big emotions. That’s a powerful lesson.
Once you feel centered, ask yourself: What’s my intention for my child?
Children need both structure and space. Unstructured time—yes, even boredom—is essential. It helps build creativity, emotional resilience, self-confidence, and self-direction. These are the very qualities that support healthy development over time.
I recommend creating gentle rhythms in the day that include both self-directed play and intentional, connected activities. This balance not only supports your child’s growth but yours as well.
Maria Natapov, Stepparenting and Co-Parenting Coach, Synergistic Stepparenting
Foster Independent Play Skills
Many parents worry that they should be constantly entertaining or engaging with their young children. However, children actually need time to play on their own. Independent, child-led play is how children develop important skills like attention, problem-solving, and emotional regulation. When they use their imagination without adult direction, their brains grow in healthy ways.
Instead of feeling guilty about not always playing with your child, try to think of independent play as a skill you’re helping them build. You might start by simply sitting nearby—like reading a book on the couch—while your child plays. If they ask you to join in, it’s okay to say, “I’m resting my brain and my body right now. I’m right here with you, but I’m going to read my book.” At first, they might be frustrated, but most children will eventually start to play on their own.
If independent play is entirely new, you can help them get started. Try setting up a small scene with toys—like a few cars on a road—and then stepping back instead of joining in. And when your child is playing independently, try not to interrupt!
Of course, children also benefit from meaningful connections with adults. Think about the activities you enjoy with your child—maybe it’s reading, cooking, doing a craft, or going for a walk—and focus on those. You don’t have to be their playmate all the time for them to feel loved and supported.
Rebecca Lesser Allen, Clinical Psychologist, Rebecca Lesser Allen & Associates
Allow Boredom to Spark Creativity
There is an incredible amount of pressure on parents these days. As a result of great psychological and early childhood development research, we know so much more about what helps children thrive. Due to this and a booming parenting industry, we have many varied resources to help guide parenting.
Unfortunately, this can also leave parents overwhelmed with information and a variety of different sources who all communicate that the information they share is most important to follow. Even better is that the information is generally good and helpful, and appeals to parents’ instincts of wanting their child to be okay and succeed!
The first thing I recommend is for parents to commend themselves for their efforts and to recognize that they are likely doing a great job. Most of the parents in my office are fabulous parents and doing excellent work, especially those trying to follow all the recommendations!
The second piece of advice is to remind them that boredom and a lack of entertainment are wonderful for children’s development. Children need to be routinely bored as this leads to increased creativity and the ability to lead themselves in new activities. When parents spend too much time and energy entertaining their children, it can actually work against their child’s development of curiosity, follow-through, and independence. It is important to balance quality time with unstructured play time, and the best part is that unstructured play time can give parents a bit of a break from being their child’s entertainment! This also helps reduce feelings of parental overwhelm.
Dr. Erica Wollerman, Licensed Clinical Psychologist, Founder, CEO, Thrive Therapy Studio
Recognize Your Parenting Efforts
You don’t need to be your child’s constant source of entertainment. The pressure to fill every hour with activities creates burnout for you and limits your child’s ability to build independence. Children thrive with unstructured time. When they get bored, they become creative. They invent games, explore their environment, and learn how to solve problems without adult direction. That’s not wasted time; it’s essential for their development.
Structured activities have a role. They build routines and expose children to new experiences. But over-scheduling eliminates rest, curiosity, and free thinking. I’ve seen this firsthand with my own three kids. The days they roam the backyard with no agenda are the days they ask better questions, cooperate more, and sleep more soundly. I’ve also led teams building early childhood programs, and the data is clear: unstructured play supports social-emotional growth, builds resilience, and improves long-term engagement in learning.
Give yourself permission to step back. You’re not failing by letting your child entertain themselves. You’re giving them space to grow. Let them be bored. Let them make messes. Let them figure things out. Structured time and free time are not in conflict – they complement each other. You don’t need perfect balance every day. What matters is giving children both the security of rhythm and the freedom to imagine on their own.
Lisa Walthers, CMO, Upkid
Provide Space for Growth and Imagination
Parenting is normally this crazy mad dash to give entertainment and structure to the kids. But what I’ve come to understand over the years is that sometimes less is more. Kids do best when they have room to play, dream, and just be. We’re so likely to fill each moment with some sort of lesson or activity, but that’s what crushes them and doesn’t allow them to learn critical skills such as problem-solving, creativity, and independence. They require free play to grow. It shows them how to learn the world on their own and stimulates creativity.
Structured activity and some free time is the best solution. Organized activities such as sports, crafts, or learning games provide quality time to learn and aid in establishing routines. But true dividends are in allowing kids the ability to play free of an agenda. You don’t have to schedule every minute of every day with advanced lessons. Allowing time to get bored provides children with the opportunity to create their solutions, develop independence, and even create creativity. As a parent, having confidence that your kids can prosper in a combination of freedom and order will leave you less stressed out and better engaged with their upbringing.
Cory Arsic, Founder, Canadian Parent
Combine Free Play with Guided Activities
I tell parents it’s not their job to entertain their child 24/7. Boredom sparks creativity and independence. Engage when you can but don’t feel guilty about stepping back. Kids need unstructured play to grow. Set boundaries, model self-care, and trust that sometimes doing “nothing” is actually doing something important. You’re not a cruise director, you’re raising a resilient human.
Balance structured and unstructured play by following your child’s needs, not rigid ratios. Free play fuels creativity and problem-solving, while structured activities like games or crafts teach cooperation and focus. For young kids, lean heavily into unstructured exploration. As they grow, gently introduce more guided activities, like 10-20% structured play for toddlers, increasing slightly with age.
But here’s the key: Structure doesn’t have to mean control. Turn daily tasks like baking and walks into playful learning. Set up open-ended activities like art supplies and puzzles and let your child choose. And never underestimate boredom. It’s the birthplace of independence.
As a therapist, I’ve seen kids thrive when parents ditch the ‘entertainer’ role. Model curiosity, join play briefly, then step back. Your job isn’t to fill every moment; it’s to create a safe space for them to explore, think critically, and occasionally follow rules with room to question ‘why’.
Trust the process. A messy house and a bored child are often signs you’re doing it right.
Aja Chavez, National Executive Director, Mission Prep Healthcare
Tolerate Boredom to Develop Essential Skills
One piece of advice as a parent of five boys I’d give to parents feeling overwhelmed by the pressure to constantly entertain their children is this: stop trying to fill every moment. Children need to learn how to tolerate boredom—it’s not just okay, it’s essential. Boredom is what sparks creativity, independence, and problem-solving. It’s the quiet space where kids start to imagine, build, explore, and make decisions on their own. If we rush in to structure every spare minute, we rob them of those opportunities.
I learned this firsthand when I scaled back on the nonstop stream of scheduled activities and screen-based entertainment. At first, there were complaints. The “I’m bored” chorus kicked in quickly. But instead of fixing it, I simply acknowledged it and gave them space. Within days, they were pulling out old building sets, drawing without prompts, and creating elaborate games with nothing more than couch cushions and cardboard boxes. That kind of self-directed play taught them far more than any app or workshop ever could.
The balance lies in intentionally carving out time for both structured activities and unstructured play. Give them a few anchor points throughout the day—like reading time, outdoor play, or a chore they’re responsible for—but leave the in-betweens open. Let them decide how to use that time, even if it starts with “nothing.” That freedom builds resilience and confidence.
You’re not failing your children by giving them space. You’re teaching them how to navigate life without constant stimulation, which is one of the most valuable lessons they’ll carry into adulthood.
Joe Benson, Cofounder, Eversite
Let Go of Guilt and Embrace Chaos
Whew—if I could hug every overwhelmed parent, I would. Especially the ones trying to keep up with all the Pinterest crafts and activity schedules.
Here’s my advice: let go of the guilt. You are not a cruise director, and your kids don’t need constant entertainment to thrive. I have two granddaughters—ages 3 and 5—and my 5-year-old is autistic. So trust me, I get it. Some days are beautifully chaotic, and others are just… chaotic.
But what I’ve learned is that unstructured play is where the real magic happens. That’s where imagination blooms. Some of our best moments come from talking to snapdragons in the garden, playing chef with herbs we’ve grown, or making “masterpieces” with cardboard and crayons. It doesn’t have to be elaborate or expensive. Structured activities have their place, sure, but so does quiet time, daydreaming, and boredom. Balance comes when you give yourself permission to not fill every second. You’re not slacking—you’re giving them room to grow. And trust me, that’s more than enough.
Melody Stevens, Owner, Design On A Dime Interiors
