What is less critical when hiring a software team member, cultural misalignment or a skill gap? Both can succumb to a turnover. In both cases, turnover costs about 1,7 x the replaced specialists’ yearly rates as you factor in lost productivity and rehiring. Why, then, hiring for cultural fit matters more than hiring for a skill fit? How much more? Is hiring with contract staffing services as culturally fit as hiring in-house? Can culture fit harm diversity? We’ve got the answers.

LEARN MORE: Read the latest business news here

Why Tech Companies Are Hiring For Cultural Fit

The Problem with Overvaluing Skill Fit

Hiring for skills alone can slow your team down. Your programmers can get all the certifications and experience, but they can become a nightmare to work with by always clashing with your team, resisting feedback, or just not vibing with your company’s way of doing things.

Now, flip the script. This is where hiring for culture fit comes in — a candidate with decent coding skills who fits your culture may pick up the technical stuff faster than you think because they’ll want to contribute and grow with the team. In the end, they’ll stay longer, saving you money in the long run.

Companies with strong culture-fit hiring practices have 30% higher team retention. That’s massive, especially in tech, where turnover can feel like a revolving door.

And it’s not just about keeping people longer, it’s about keeping them happier. A cohesive team is a productive team. When everyone’s on the same page, you spend less time putting out fires and more time building cool stuff.

Balancing Act: Skills vs. Values

When you nail the mix of skills and culture fit, you’re not just hiring employees; you’re creating a team that can tackle anything together. Here’s the sweet spot: a 70/30 approach.

  • 70% culture fit. Look for alignment with your company’s values, adaptability, and soft skills like communication and teamwork.
  • 30% skill fit. Ensure they’ve got the technical chops or at least a solid foundation to build on.

Many companies flip these numbers, but in software teams, where collaboration is king, the 70/30 rule keeps things humming along.

How to Screen for Culture Fit Without the Fluff

Alright, so how do you figure out if someone’s a good culture fit?

• Start with your company values. If “continuous learning” is one of your core values, ask candidates about the last skill they picked up or how they approach learning new technologies. Is their passion evident when they discuss it? That’s a good sign.

• Behavioral questions are your best friend. Forget hypothetical scenarios. Instead, ask, “Can you describe a time your team faced difficulties? How did you manage it? How did you handle it?” Their answer will give you a peek into their work style and attitude.

• Test their adaptability. For tech roles, change is constant. Throw them a curveball in the interview — a sudden change in requirements or a tricky problem — and see how they react. The goal isn’t to stress them out but to gauge how they handle uncertainty.

If you’re finding it tough to balance hard and soft skills, consider contract staffing services. These services can connect you with pre-vetted professionals who not only bring the necessary skills but are also assessed for culture fit. Hiring your team members as contractors is a great way to test the waters with candidates before committing to long-term hires.

Red Flags to Watch For

Let’s not sugarcoat this: some candidates might be great at faking culture fit. But you can easily declassify them by paying attention to a few warning signs.

• Over-agreeing. If they’re mirroring everything you say without adding their perspective, they might be telling you what you want to hear.

• Blaming others. If their stories of past jobs are all about how bad their team or manager was, they might struggle with accountability.

• Lack of curiosity. If they’re not asking questions about your company culture, they might not care about it.

Don’t Overlook: The Insights About Culture Fit

Culture Fit Can Evolve

Here’s something not everyone talks about: your company culture isn’t static. As your business grows, so will your culture. This means hiring for cultural fit isn’t one-and-done. Regularly review your values and priorities and adjust your hiring process to match them. Think of it as upgrading your software — it’s part of staying competitive.

Onboarding Is the Bridge Between Culture and Skills

Even the best hire needs a good onboarding process to thrive. Think of onboarding as the bridge between skill and culture fit. Use this time to set clear expectations, introduce them to the team dynamic, and reinforce your company values.

Pro tip: pair new hires with a mentor. It’s a great way to help them integrate faster and build relationships within the team.

Diversity and Culture Fit Aren’t Opposites

A lot of folks hear “culture fit” and think it means hiring a team of clones — people who look, think, and act the same. Guess what? That’s not a culture hire, that’s a creativity killer.

Hiring for culture fit is not about hiring someone who’s exactly like everyone else, not shared hobbies or personalities. It’s about hiring someone whose values align with your company’s mission, someone who gets how you work, and thrives in it. For example, if your software team thrives on collaboration, you need someone who’s comfortable brainstorming and building on ideas, not just a solo genius who disappears into their code cave. The next time you’re hiring, don’t just ask, “Can you code?”, “What’s your favorite programming language?” or “What’s your Myers-Briggs type? Ask, “Will you thrive here?” Trust us, it makes all the difference.

Hiring for culture fit and diversity can absolutely coexist. In fact, they should. A diverse team brings fresh ideas, different perspectives, and better problem-solving. Just make sure your definition of culture fit isn’t so narrow that it excludes people with different backgrounds or experiences.