In search of cost-effective email marketing strategies tailored for small businesses, we’ve gathered insights from top industry professionals, including marketing directors and email marketing managers. From targeting audiences based on interests to repurposing content as lead magnets, explore the eighteen diverse and budget-friendly tactics these experts recommend. Here are 18 best practices for email marketing on a small budget:

READ MORE: AZ Big 100: 50 Arizona business leaders to watch in 2024

  • Target Audience Based on Interests
  • Personalize and Segment Early On
  • Optimize Transactional Email Opportunities
  • Create Urgency with FOMO Tactics
  • Maintain Regular Newsletter Schedule
  • Build an Opt-In Email List
  • Engage with Content Co-Creation
  • Send Annual Holiday Greetings
  • Utilize the Power of P.S.
  • Conduct A/B Testing for Optimization
  • Enable Email Sharing Options
  • Incorporate User-Generated Content
  • Collect Emails at Physical Checkout
  • Start with Free Email Marketing Tools
  • Include Interactive Email Elements
  • Embrace Visuals in Email Campaigns
  • Set Up Trigger-Based Email Sequences
  • Repurpose Content as Lead Magnets

Target Audience Based on Interests

Targeting selective individuals based on their interests and demographic information is a cost-effective email marketing strategy for small businesses. It is fair to state that most small businesses would want to advertise their product to everyone around the globe. However, in the realm of digital marketing, this is not a wise strategy. Small business owners should be aware of the priorities and needs of their potential customers. Moreover, these businesses should also be aware of the range of their products or services. 

By learning about the consumer behavior of their potential and existing customers, small businesses can narrow their advertising target effectively. This allows small businesses to save on marketing costs that would have otherwise been spent on sending emails to dead ends. Below are some tips on narrowing the marketing target to secure higher results and better retention rates. 

Learn about your targeted audience with the help of demographics. By thoroughly studying the demographic segmentation of the market, you can filter out customers based on their age, gender, etc. Furthermore, you can use social media platforms to get email sign-ups from customers by incentivizing the process. This way, you can continue to learn more about the customer pool while simultaneously increasing your email list. 

You can also use a wide range of analytical tools to analyze customer behavior and the shortcomings in your marketing campaign. Tools and tactics like survey forms, website analytics, CRM data, social media insights, A/B testing, and email analytics can be resourceful. These analytical tools give you insight into which email copy or list was more effective than others. Moreover, you also learn about the conversion rates through information like webpage visits and click-through rates. 

In conclusion, instead of going all out on your email marketing campaign, you should target and tailor your audience wisely. This is a cost-effective email marketing strategy that works well for small business owners. This strategy not only saves them a substantial amount of marketing cost but also helps in getting better results from email marketing campaigns.

Muhammad Ibtehaj Ansari, SEO Analyst, Digital Auxilius

Personalize and Segment Early On

One thing I suggest to all startups I work with is to start segmenting and personalizing emails early. In today’s age of chatbots, many people like the individual feel when you can speak to their name, their likes, and provide recommendations. Starting small with the first name and adding in the rest as you grow and they explore will create an impact to last. 

Also, by segmenting based on their likes, you will also provide content that speaks to them; they wouldn’t want to receive an email solely for blue widgets when they have expressed their love for pink widgets.

Kari Massoth, Email Marketing Manager, ModMed

Optimize Transactional Email Opportunities

Small businesses often use transactional emails, but they don’t always customize them. These emails are sent when a customer abandons a cart, completes a purchase, or when an order ships out. They are important opportunities to connect with customers along their shopping journey. With some simple optimization, these emails can drive more sales for almost no extra cost.

For example, abandoned-cart emails that are personalized and sent quickly can recover up to 15-20% of abandoned carts. Delivery-confirmation emails that highlight other products a customer might like can generate extra incremental revenue. And order follow-ups sent after delivery asking for product reviews can build social proof.

The best part is that once the initial templates are created, sending these automated emails has near-zero marginal cost at scale. So, small e-commerce merchants get the benefit of what feels like one-to-one messaging to the customer with no heavy lifting.

Ricci Masero, Marketing Manager, Intellek

Create Urgency with FOMO Tactics

A highly effective email marketing strategy that has proven successful for us, and I believe can work wonders for small businesses as well, is harnessing the power of FOMO, the fear of missing out.

In my opinion, the most impactful email marketing approach for small businesses is to tap into FOMO, especially in the subject line. Using compelling words can significantly increase the chances of your emails being opened. Phrases like “Limited-time,” “Limited quantities,” and “Going fast” create a sense of urgency, prompting recipients to act immediately by opening the email.

To gauge the success of this tactic, I recommend utilizing small-business dashboard software. This tool allows you to measure and analyze the impact of your FOMO-driven email marketing campaigns, helping you fine-tune your strategy for maximum results.

Precious Abacan, Marketing Director, Softlist

Maintain Regular Newsletter Schedule

Sending out regular newsletters is a cost-effective email marketing strategy for all small businesses. 

Maintaining a regular newsletter schedule should include a mix of educational, informative, and promotional content, such as summaries of recent blog posts, updates on new products or services, and relevant industry news. This keeps the audience informed and engaged, and helps nurture a relationship with them. 

Newsletters are also a great tool to drive traffic to your website and social media channels, enhancing your overall digital presence. The key is to maintain a balance in content that caters to the interests of your audience while subtly promoting your business.

Kate Wojewoda-Celinska, Marketing Manager, Spacelift

Build an Opt-In Email List

Never buy an email list. Small businesses sometimes purchase a list so they can build out a list quickly and inexpensively, but it’s one use of your money that rarely returns a solid ROI. It takes time to build out an email list from scratch, but you can use low-cost channels like social media to find the right audience. 

When people voluntarily choose to receive your emails, they’re already showing an investment in your brand. Purchased email lists tend to be low-quality and increase spam complaints, which will absolutely destroy your deliverability rates. Stick to opt-in email lists, and remember that 10 highly engaged users will always outweigh 100 disengaged and disinterested ones.

James Delapa, Director of Digital Marketing, Wrike

Engage with Content Co-Creation

We often send out emails, but how often do we ask clients for their input regarding these emails? The content co-creation approach for email marketing is cost-effective and highly effective. 

When we noticed our email marketing campaign was stagnating, we resorted to asking our recipients to contribute a shared piece of content that interests them. We thought they would be more likely to open and engage with our emails if they felt we cared to ask for their input, compared to only being on the receiving end. Some shared community resources, blog posts, etc., and by asking for their input, we presented our company as an inclusive and collaborative brand. 

In three months, we managed to overcome the stagnation in our email marketing campaign. We increased our open and response rates and noticed a surge in referrals. A small business looking for higher email marketing results on a limited budget can consider content co-creation.

Dmytro Sokhach, Digital Marketer, SEO Entrepreneur, CEO, Editorial.Link

Send Annual Holiday Greetings

Especially in the moving industry, we know that people aren’t going to need our services all that often, so simply staying in mind as an option is an extra-important first step to converting. 

One very low-cost way we do this is with annual holiday greetings. We send everyone on our email list greetings for Christmas, the Fourth of July, Thanksgiving, and Memorial Day every year. You’ve only got to make these emails once; you can send the exact same message to everyone on your list. It’s more likely to get through spam filters, and it’s a simple way to remind customers that you’re an option so that they think of you when they need your services.

Nick Valentino, VP of Market Operations, Bellhop

Utilize the Power of P.S.

One cost-effective email marketing strategy that works well for small businesses is leveraging the power of the P.S. statement at the end of your emails. Often overlooked, the postscript is a prime location to include a compelling call to action, a special offer, or a personal note that can drive engagement. 

Since many readers naturally skim to the end of an email, the P.S. can capture attention and provide a final persuasive nudge, leading to higher conversion rates. It’s simple, doesn’t cost extra, and effectively utilizes the existing structure of your email to enhance the impact of your marketing message.

Jaya Iyer, Marketing Manager, Teranga Digital Marketing LTD

Conduct A/B Testing for Optimization

Run A/B testing to fine-tune email marketing campaigns efficiently. Experiment with at least two different elements of a certain part of your email campaign and see which of the two yields better results. 

Continue running these A/B tests until you find the best version of each element in your email that you know will work well with your audience, instead of leaving it to guesswork. Doing this will save you money, time, and effort in the long run because it optimizes your email marketing campaigns, ensuring you hit your targets.

Luciano Bellacci, Head of Marketing, Group Online

Enable Email Sharing Options

I highly recommend including sharing options in your email marketing strategy. It’s actually a simple but useful way to enhance your email campaigns!

For example, consider configuring your newsletter for easy distribution by adding features that allow readers to share your emails. Besides forwarding emails, you can encourage subscribers to share your mailings with their friends, family, and followers using built-in share options. Most email marketing platforms, like Mailchimp, provide the option to enable various sharing features such as a Campaign URL link, Facebook share button, Twitter share button, and LinkedIn share button.

Believe me, enabling these URL and social sharing options can expose your emails to a wider audience, which not only helps more people discover your business but can also encourage them to sign up for your emails.

Patrick Beltran, Marketing Director, Ardoz Digital

Incorporate User-Generated Content

Encourage your clients to provide reviews, testimonials, or images of their purchases or anything relevant to your products or services. Use this user-generated content in your email marketing. Tell success stories of your clients and highlight how your goods and services have improved their lives. 

This, in my opinion, might support the development of credibility and trust among your audience. Encourage consumers to submit content by holding UGC contests or giveaways, and then highlight the top entries in your communications. This not only increases engagement but also provides your campaigns with new, genuine material without requiring expensive development. 

Utilizing user-generated content fosters a sense of community among your clients while also giving your emails more legitimacy. I think it’s a cost-effective way of utilizing the influence of word-of-mouth and social proof in marketing.

Graham McCormack, SEO Specialist, Graham SEO

Collect Emails at Physical Checkout

When I started my first business, I always thought that building an email list would require thousands of dollars in ads or high amounts of traffic coming to my website.

But one day, I had an idea. I decided to put an email sign-up form at my physical store so customers could sign up during checkout and get priority access to new sales.

This worked like a charm. Within the first three weeks, I built a list of over 100 email addresses and did this without spending a cent.

So, if you have a physical store and you’re looking to build an email list on a budget, I highly suggest having a sign-up form at checkout.

Scott Lieberman, Owner, Touchdown Money

Start with Free Email Marketing Tools

Take advantage of free offers—that’s one of the most important things that you should understand when you’re just getting started. As your business grows, you can always look at paid plans, but for now, keeping your expenses as low as possible while you’re navigating the world of running a business and implementing email marketing should be a priority. 

There are several popular email marketing software providers that give you access to a free version. Yes, there are limitations, but when you’re in the early stages, you usually don’t need more than what they offer. MailChimp is an excellent example, but other options like GetResponse, AWeber, and MailPoet are also good choices.

Joe Flanagan, Marketing Manager, Ukulele Tabs

Include Interactive Email Elements

I like to include interactive elements in my emails, like polls or quizzes. These fun elements engage subscribers and encourage them to interact with the content. The feedback or data collected can be invaluable for understanding my audience better. 

This strategy is cost-effective because it adds value to the emails without requiring a big budget and enhances user engagement in a playful and informative way.

Brooke Webber, Head of Marketing, Ninja Patches

Embrace Visuals in Email Campaigns

One cost-effective email marketing strategy that works wonders for small businesses is embracing visuals. People love engaging content that’s easy on the eyes, so focus on creating visually appealing emails. 

Small businesses can add short videos or eye-catching graphics to their campaigns to convey their message instead of drowning the audience in paragraphs of text. Visuals not only grab attention faster but also leave a lasting impression. Plus, they’re more likely to be shared, making it possible to increase their reach without spending more.

Daniel Willmott, Founder,

Set Up Trigger-Based Email Sequences

Trigger-based introductory email marketing sequences tell the story of your business, warm up new leads, and incentivize them to take further action. For small-business email marketing, technology is your best friend, and you should always set up an automated introductory email sequence that tells your story in a few quick emails once a trigger is met.

Max Wesman, Chief Operating Officer, GoodHire

Repurpose Content as Lead Magnets

The most cost-effective tactic I’ve leveraged successfully is repurposing existing high-performing blog content into a lead magnet offered in exchange for sign-ups.

Rather than rushing to purchase expensive email tools or hiring a dedicated copywriter to craft extensive newsletter content from scratch, I compiled my best evergreen articles around topics like budgeting, paying off debt, and side hustles into a comprehensive money guide eBook.

This eBook provides immense value, packed with my top money tips, while also serving as irresistible bait to compel visitors to hand over their inboxes in exchange for the free download. It quickly became the cornerstone for luring dedicated email subscribers at scale.

Once their contact information is captured, I can then nurture those high-intent leads over time through automated drip campaigns, focusing engagement back to the blog. This system reliably builds my most loyal audience.

Repackaging proven content to incentivize opt-ins beats developing resource-heavy sequences or assets before confirming their appeal. It kick-starts small business email lists through value exchange rather than interruption.

Brian Meiggs, Founder, My Millennial Guide